One Year in Hell: The Aftermath of the 1877 Lykens Mine Fire

On a cold winter evening in December 1876, Dr. Charles H. Miller stood before the Lykens Harmonic and Literary Association and prepared to speak from his prepared notes. His topic: growing up in Pennsylvania’s Coal Region during the area’s development in the decade before the Civil War.

He opened with these lines:

[T]he sketch that is intended to be presented to you [remembers] the primitive days of a town since grown into importance and position; a town largely increasing in trade and population; a town now the outlet of almost a half million tons of coal annually; whose location is among the richest anthracite coal beds in the State; whose future is the most promising , and whose present is full of prosperity…

Nine days later, on New Year’s Day 1877, the prosperous community of Lykens, Pennsylvania was brought to its knees by a devastating mine fire. The disaster changed Miller’s life and the lives of thousands of Dauphin County residents forever.

Read Part I: “One Spark: The 1877 Lykens Mine Fire” 

While the fire inside the workings of the Lykens Valley Coal Company raged out of control, residents in Lykens and neighboring Wiconisco Township feared for their livelihoods. More than 3,000 people lived in the two communities, and the local economy was built atop the area’s valuable anthracite coal mines.

Lykens, Pennsylvania

A newspaper correspondent described the fear that settled over the community:

The general impression is among those who understand the topography of these mines that the fire cannot be extinguished; that it must rage until it has exhausted itself for want of fuel. So strong is this conviction among the people of the neighborhood that a panic exists, seizing men in their business transactions, and impelling them to the belief that their local interests have been swallowed up by the effects of the fire which is destroying the mines, as all business there of an individual or general character, merchandizing and manufacturing, is made dependent on the mining interest.

The Lykens Record reported on January 5, 1877 that “a feeling of gloom and foreboding is apparent among all classes.” The editors concluded:

The fire in the mines at this season of the year will prove a dire calamity to a large proportion of our citizens, who depended almost entirely upon earnings there for the necessaries of life. And what adds still more to their misfortunes, work, at greatly reduced wages, has been very slack for several months, and but very meager pay could be realized under the most favorable circumstances. 

The fire occurred at a particularly dismal time for the miners and workers in Wiconisco Township and across the Coal Region. Mired in the fourth year of “the Long Depression,” industry remained slack across the nation. With a depressed economy, orders for anthracite coal remained scarce across the Coal Region.

A small number of workers entered the burning mine to assist in efforts to put the fire out, but the vast majority of the 800 miners and workers attached to the mines and related industries in Bear Gap were thrown out of work. The situation looked dire – damage was estimated in excess of $1 million and fierce debate raged over whether the Lykens colliery would ever reopen.

The Short Mountain Slope at Bear Gap

Referencing the Lykens coal trade’s importance to Dauphin County’s economy, the Harrisburg Independent opined on January 9 that “under these circumstances our city can well lend a helping hand in endeavoring to stay the progress of the devastating fire that threatens the total annihilation of that lucrative trade.”

Workers were thrown out of what little work remained in the dead of winter. Even when the fire was declared extinguished on March 2, 1877 after raging for more than six weeks, the future remained gloomy for the laborers at Lykens and Wiconisco. On the same day they reported the success of the firefighting effort, the Harrisburg Independent recorded “a number of families are about moving from Lykens to Tower City, where they have obtained employment.”

The hard-hit community breathed a sigh of relief when company officials declared their intent to rebuild the colliery in mid-May, but as the Lykens Register recorded, “the prosperity of the town and entire surrounding country has suffered greatly already from the calamity.”

As the weather warmed, labor tensions increased to a fever pitch across the country by the beginning of summer in 1877. Pressure continued to build as workers’ pay was slashed and conditions worsened for the miners and laborers of the Coal Region. When collieries began to close due to lack of business, workers felt the blow acutely. Many rushed to join unions and workers’ associations. Others called for violence.

“The expression of the dissatisfied workingmen is, that, as the present pay is not enough for them and their families to subsist upon,” reported the Chicago Tribune on July 7, “they might as well strike for an advance and be ‘locked out,’ as to continue work will only contribute so much more wealth to the unscrupulous and speculative corporations…”

This infectious mood spread through the Coal Region and made its way south to Lykens and Wiconisco Township.

“Have our manufacturers and operatives forgot that one hundred years ago our hero, George Washington, was fighting to have a free and independent nation?” queried “Workingman” in a letter addressed from Wiconisco on August 6.

This letter was published by the Harrisburg Independent in August 1877.

The author continued hearkening back to the days of the American Revolution:

But what caused the colonies to war with England, was it a plot to destroy their former mode of Government? Nay, it was for the protection of their own and our own industries and from being suppressed to starvation with taxes on tea, etc. 

Now, what looks more like it then is what we have this day in this free land America; the working class are suppressed to starvation in the first place, labor is cut down to $1.25 per day, and when wages are paid 30 percent, deducted from their net earnings leaving a small ratio to the family of man, wife, and six children…

I fear unless it comes to a change that we will have the pleasure to do our forefathers’ work over…

This revolutionary fervor raged across the nation throughout the summer, and the fires of revolt were further fanned when railroad workers in Martinsburg, West Virginia walked off the job and began blocking rail traffic on one of the busiest railines in America. Thousands of railroad workers followed suit and violence scourged the nation’s industrial corridors. In the Coal Region, riots broke out in Shamokin in what became known as the “Shamokin Uprising.” Two people were killed and more than a dozen wounded when a sheriff’s posse opened fire into a crowd there on July 25.

Labor War
Headline in the Harrisburg Independent, July 26, 1877.

Beneath this nightmarish landscape of mob violence based on labor strife lay an undercurrent of ethnic tensions in the Coal Region as well. For years, attacks on collieries and colliery management by the so-called “Molly Maguires” heightened tensions across the mountains and valleys of eastern Pennsylvania. In a landmark trial in 1876, a series of alleged Molly Maguires were convicted of murder and sentenced to death in Pottsville and Mauch Chunk. On June 21, 1877, ten Irishmen plunged to their deaths from the gallows in a series of executions that remain controversial into the 21st century.

Related image
“The Day of the Rope,” June 21, 1877 in Pottsville, Pennsylvania

Against this backdrop of chaos and bloodshed across the United States, the people of Lykens Borough and Wiconisco Township suffered.

“The directors of the poor should render some assistance to the many indigent persons at Lykens and vicinity,” wrote the Harrisburg Telegraph in early August. “They are unable to make a living on account of the mines being stopped, and forced to make begging tours through the country to get enough to keep soul and body together.”

Harrisburg Independent, September 27, 1877

The same reporter acknowledged that rural areas to the west of Wiconisco Township were overwhelmed by hungry residents traveling from the industrial areas. “The farmers in Lykens Valley are greatly imposed upon by beggars,” he wrote.

In Lykens, efforts were underway to assist the indigent members of the community suffering through the late summer heat. In early September, a council of citizens met in Odd Fellows’ Hall to “devise means to assist the suffering poor of the borough [in] the coming winter.”  The local correspondent for the Harrisburg Independent noted that “the hall was crowded to such an extent that we were unable to hear the proceedings or gain entrance.”

Another citizen managed to make his way into such a meeting. He described what was discussed:

A meeting, called sometime since by the borough authorities, to devise means for the relief of the poor of our town, disclosed the startling fact that over 100 families in this small community were at the time destitute both of employment and the means of procuring the necessaries of life. This is a most gloomy outlook for the coming winter, and should business fail to revive much suffering will ensue. Many express a hope that our Government will take some action that will relieve the general stringency and bring back prosperity. Whether this hope is well founded time will show.

The colliery’s superintendent, E.C. Hanna, opened up the culm banks on the northern and western edge of the community for the community to pick through. This provided heating and a potential source of income for those in Lykens and Wiconisco in order to assist them through the autumn and into the winter months.

Others turned to crime. The newspapers are full of petty theft, pick-pocketing, and other minor criminal activity. Farmers again lamented the “sharpers” who appeared from the coal regions and did not leave until they received food and other supplies. “Small thieving has been practiced hereabouts to some extent recently, the articles stolen consisting principally of food,” wrote another Lykens correspondent for a Harrisburg press.

These scenes of hunger and poverty were little abated by promising news from the workings of the Lykens Valley mines. By November, the water that had been poured down the slopes into the mountain to put out the inferno had been pumped out of the workings. A celebration was held in Lykens to commemorate the potential return of business, investment, and prosperity to their stricken community.

Yet, it was April 1878 before the first shipment of anthracite coal made its way from the workings in Wiconisco Township. The community began to rebuild in the wake of a desolate 15 months with little business. Economic conditions began to improve around the nation following a desperate summer of labor strife, violence, and bloodshed.

For some families in Lykens and Wiconisco, however, recovery never quite took place. The family of Dr. Charles H. Miller was one such group. His father, Joseph Miller, was a former Dauphin County clerk and had significant investments in real estate in the northern part of the county. When the fire devastated the mines, property values plummeted. As a family friend reported, “between 1877 and 1880, the fortunes of the family were swept away.”

Trained as a doctor at the University of Pennsylvania, Charles H. Miller turned to writing while his family’s money helped support him. This is how he came to be speaking in front of the Lykens Harmonic and Literary Association on December 22, 1876. Following the mine fire and subsequent economic collapse in Lykens, Dr. Miller headed west toward Kansas. Unable to make a living in the West, he made his way back toward his hometown at Lykens.

A friend in Lykens received a letter in early 1889 from Dr. Miller, saying “he would starve in the West and would try to work his way East.” That journey ended in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania in early June when a railroad worker found Dr. Charles H. Miller lying unconscious with significant blunt force trauma to the skull. He died several days later.

Sad Story
New York Times, February 23, 1890

Dr. Miller’s sad story perfectly represents the fate that befell many residents in the northern end of Dauphin County in the wake of the Lykens Mine Fire of 1877. The fire took place against a backdrop of momentous national events that both influenced and impacted events in Lykens and Wiconisco Township. By examining the experiences of the working class through such a disastrous event, a clearer picture of why radical ideas reigned and violence broke out in so many American communities in one of our America’s most chaotic years.

Photograph at Top: Lykens, PA in the mid-19th century (

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

5 thoughts on “One Year in Hell: The Aftermath of the 1877 Lykens Mine Fire

  1. Hello. Thank you for this article. My ancestor’s Jonas and Barbara Miller were highlighted here as well their son, Charles H Miller who was found murdered on a rail car trying to make his way back home. It’s frustrating when something mysterious like this happens in the past; as it can create a question mark for many generations to come. Susan Parker Rosen-Latham


  2. Hello, I just thought I would let you know I read this and enjoyed it very much. My Schindler family all worked the mines in Lykins during this period before moving to Harrisburg in Late 1800 to early 1900 to work on the railroads.
    I shall look to see what else you have written about this area.
    Thanks, Mike

    Liked by 1 person

  3. This is excellent historical information. My Great Grandfather Jeremiah Splane is buried in the Irish Catholic Cemetery with his wife. He emigrated from Ireland with three other Spillane brothers. I suspect the name was anglicized to Splane because of the anti-Irish sentiment and the need to sound more English to get work. I assume he worked in the Short Mountain mine. He emigrated in 1850 at the age of 25 and died in Lykens in 1885. There is a listing in the mine accident registry for Jeremiah Splann. This is probably him with a misspelling. Thank for the information.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s