Letters from War – Ideas for a World War II memorial in Pine Grove and a dislike of monuments – 1945

This is part of our “Letters from War” series documenting the World War II letters of Irvin Schwartz of Pine Grove, PA. The letters were all published in the West Schuylkill Press-Herald between 1943 and 1945. 

Read the previous letter here

While Sergeant Irvin Schwartz remained in a military hospital in early March 1945, he mused on the idea of a war memorial in his hometown of Pine Grove, Pennsylvania. The young soldier hated the idea of a monument or statue dedicated to the soldiers who were winning the Second World War as he wrote. Still nursing a shrapnel wound to his leg, he had other ideas for ways to honor the sacrifices of Schuylkill County soldiers. He wrote to the West Schuylkill Press-Herald to share his suggestion:

Schwartz 1944 (1)
A 1944 photograph of Irvin Schwartz

In the General Hospital

In Belgium

March 3, 1945


Dear Mr. Reber:

A few words on a subject spoken about immensely in recent letters in the. In the majority of letters I am receiving currently, my friends and relatives in and about Pine Grove mention the possibility of “the Iris Town” some day erecting somewhat of a memorial for Pine Grove’s men and women in the service.

Plans for such a project will evidently start in the not-too-distant future which caused me to write to Mr. Speidel and suggest a memorial other than the ordinary one – a just plain monument. I hope the plan will be carried out, as I am quite certain the idea is far more pleasing to all of Pine Grove’s sons and daughters in the wars.

In our opinion, statues are “useless” war memorials and should be discouraged. Parks, athletic fields, hospitals, swimming pools, etc., are far better ways of honoring Pine Grove’s war heroes. One example is this. Already, Pine Grove High School is badly in need of a larger and more modern gymnasium. Not only for the benefit of the school’s over 400 students, but for hundreds of basketball fans as well.

In the near future we will be forced to build a new gym. So why not have it in honor of our servicemen and give the gym the name of “Veterans’ Alumni Gymnasium” or something similar. Also in the sports line, P.G.H.S. will undoubtedly have a greater outdoor sports program as son as this conflict is over and a new football and baseball stadium would be greeted by thousands. And such a memorial could be named Soldiers’ Memorial Stadium, Soldiers’ Field, Alumni Stadium, or anything in that order.

Anyway, monuments are useless as far as we are concerned, as well as you at home, so why not give the town a gymnasium, park, pool, or stadium? It’s just a suggestion.

Irvin R. Schwartz,

U.S. Army

Featured Image: Sergeant Irvin Schwartz and an illustration of an American soldier at the grave of a comrade, 1945

This is part of a series titled: “Letters from War.” Read more of the letters written by Irvin Schwartz during World War II

Like what you see here? Follow Wynning History on Facebook!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

2 thoughts on “Letters from War – Ideas for a World War II memorial in Pine Grove and a dislike of monuments – 1945

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s