“1917” – A film experience that brings the horror of World War I to life

If you are looking for a worthwhile movie experience this winter, look no further than the stunning World War I movie 1917.

While the film focuses on the British perspective on the Western Front, I did find a connection to Pennsylvania’s anthracite coal fields. It came in the form of a scene near the end of the film (no spoilers, I promise!)

In the film, there is a scene in a “casualty clearing station” or first aid station near the front-line trenches. The scene reveals the shocking devastation caused by machine guns, artillery, and small arms fire on World War I battlefields. This scene was quite illuminating to me, as previously on Wynning History, I wrote about a doctor from Tower City, Pennsylvania who served with the British Expeditionary Force in such a place.

In the blog post from March 2018, “Schuylkill County native became a British war hero in March 1918,” I examined how Dr. Daniel E. Berney earned a medal for merit while serving in a first aid station at the front lines during a German offensive in early 1918.

Berney Photograph
Dr. Daniel E. Berney

This line from a letter Dr. Berney wrote to his brother Tim in Tower City struck me as particularly poignant:

When the Germans made their first drive on March 21st., they hit the British line where I had been assigned as Medical Officer. My corps never did know when to quit, and when we saw our line slowly pressed back I leaving the helpless wounded fail prisoner to the Huns, I guess it was that inner stuff of the Schuylkill miner boy which bubbled out, boys. [An] American never deserts a comrade. What say you British?

“Aye, aye, sir. Come on Doctor.”

All day they shuttled with helpless burdens from the front line to the first aid station as fast as [possible.] It was a first-aid, a lift, a lean, a carry, a stretcher.

Tim: it was a slaughter house Hell till 5 o’clock, then we also got caught. As a fresh row of German machine guns swept back our ranks one stabbed me in the thigh. First Sergeant, none braver nor more loyal ever lived, grabbed me as I fell and bore me on his shoulders; second bullet knocked off the heel of my shoe; a third grazed my knee and a 4th, oh horrors, split open the Sergeant’s helmet.

Two stretcher-bearers saw us fall equally fearless and faithful they rolled me on their stretcher and started back for a shell hole, both were dead before we got back there.

I dragged myself in till night fainted at 10 o’clock started to drag myself to the rear; arrived alone at the dressing station 2 miles back at 4 o’clock next morning, exhausted, blood-empty, but living…

Read the full post here

First Aid
A Royal Army Medical Corps first aid station in WW1. (Wellcome Collection)

The scene in 1917 brings such a first aid station to life. But that’s just one short scene in a massive film that endeavors to put the horror and hopelessness of the First World War to life.

I hope you’ll consider checking out the film – and when you do, drop a comment below and let us know what you think!


Interested in learning more about the First World War. I highly recommend Dan Carlin’s “Hardcore History” episodes about the conflict. In a six-part podcast series, “Blueprint for Armaggedon” explores the conflict from multiple perspectives, using primary sources to reveal the realities of the Great War. Carlin answers a lot of questions and raises many more about soldiers’ motivations, the new technology, and the complete insanity of the First World War. 


Featured Image: A scene from the film 1917. 


Like what you see here? Follow Wynning History on Facebook!

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s