Thanksgiving History | Best of Jake Wynn – Public Historian

Thanksgiving has always been my favorite holiday (yes, even more than Christmas). Over the years, I’ve pulled together stories about how the holiday was celebrated during some of the most tumultuous moments in the nation’s history.

Here are some of the top Thanksgiving history stories from the blog over the years. Enjoy – and let us know of any future holiday history you’d like us to explore in the comments below.


On November 24, 1864, the residents of Schuylkill County had much to celebrate and to be thankful for. On the second national celebration of Thanksgiving, the United States Army had begun a string of remarkable victories and the Confederacy seemed on the brink of defeat. The Civil War, it seemed, was entering its final stage.

Read the Full Story

Thanksgiving 1861 and a Pennsylvania Civil War Soldier’s Missing Turkey

Uncover how the soldiers of the 96th Pennsylvania coped with holiday expectations amid wartime challenges and the struggles of one of the unit’s members to find a missing turkey sent to him from his hometown before the holiday.

Read the Full Story

Schuylkill County’s first Thanksgiving | November 1845

On November 27, 1845, Pottsville, Pennsylvania celebrated its first Thanksgiving, a day introduced in the Keystone State by Governor Francis Shunk. The town’s churches filled with those giving thanks for a prosperous year, a tradition that later grew into a national holiday during the Civil War.

Read the Full Story

A Thanksgiving sermon in the aftermath of the 1902 Coal Strike

On Thanksgiving Day 1902, Reverend John Hensyl stood before an audience in Shenandoah’s Presbyterian Church at Oak and White streets. Before him sat a large audience from numerous Protestant churches in the Schuylkill County mining community prepared to hear a Thanksgiving message.

Read the Full Story

Illustration of a chaotic scene depicting a bar fight with several men confronting each other, wielding weapons, and surrounded by a smoky atmosphere.

A Thanksgiving Night bar-room murder in a Schuylkill County patch town | November 1868

On Thanksgiving night in 1868, a bar-room altercation in the mining village of West Delaware Mines, Pennsylvania, turned deadly.

After an argument over a drink, Edward Pursel fatally shot Civil War veteran John Duffy.

Read the Full Story


More Thanksgiving Stories from Jake Wynn – Public Historian

Celebrating Thanksgiving Day in Lykens, PA | 1871

Winslow Homer depicts class divide at Thanksgiving holiday | 1860

Thanksgiving in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania | November 1943

Coal mines operated on Thanksgiving Day as World War II raged | November 1943


Subscribe to the latest from Jake Wynn – Public Historian

Enter your email below to receive the newest stories.

One thought on “Thanksgiving History | Best of Jake Wynn – Public Historian

Leave a Reply